Insurance Says Your Roof Needs Replacing? | Springfield, MO | Titan Roofing
☎ Call Us! Free Estimate
Aerial view of a Tudor-style home with a shingle roof

Your Insurance Company Says Your Roof Needs Replacing. Now What?

It usually shows up as a letter you weren't expecting. Your homeowners insurance company says it reviewed "aerial imagery" of your house, found wear, granule loss, debris, or overhanging trees, and either wants the roof replaced or won't renew your policy. A lot of people never knew anyone looked at their roof at all.

If that just happened to you, you're not alone. Homeowners all over the country are asking about this right now, including here in Missouri, and the answer is not always "go buy a new roof tomorrow." Here's what's going on, what Missouri law says, and the steps that actually help.

Why insurers are looking at your roof from the sky

Insurance companies decide which homes they want to cover using their own underwriting guidelines. More and more of them check roofs with satellite and drone photos instead of sending a person out. The Missouri Department of Commerce and Insurance has told reporters that drone and satellite use isn't prohibited in the state, and that it doesn't regulate when insurers inspect homes (Kansas City Star).

Software then flags things like:

Sometimes the photo is right. Sometimes it's an old image, a shadow, or a shed that got mistaken for the house. Homeowners on Reddit have shared both kinds of stories: one person had a nonrenewal withdrawn after trimming trees and sending fresh photos of a roof the insurer thought had moss, while another found the insurer's records simply didn't show the roof had already been replaced.

In Springfield and the rest of southwest Missouri, hail and wind are a big part of why insurers watch roofs closely. Roofs here take a beating, and a 15 or 20 year old shingle roof may have more wear than it looks like from the driveway. See how long asphalt shingles really last in Springfield.

What Missouri law says about a nonrenewal notice

Missouri has specific rules for when an insurer decides not to renew your homeowners policy. Under RSMo 375.004:

A nonrenewal is different from a mid-term cancellation, which has its own rules under RSMo 375.003. Either way, the key point is the same: a nonrenewal notice doesn't mean your coverage ends the day the letter arrives. Find the date your policy actually ends and work backward from it.

What to do if you get the letter

1. Read the reason and the end date

Write down exactly what the insurer says is wrong and the date coverage stops. That reason is what you'll respond to. If it says "roof condition," ask what specifically.

2. Ask for the photos

Call your agent or the company and ask for the images and the report the decision was based on. Many insurers will share them, sometimes with problem spots circled. You can't fix or dispute something you can't see.

3. Get a real, in-person roof inspection

An aerial photo can't lift a shingle or check a soft spot in the decking. Have a roofer get on the roof and look at what the insurer flagged. Ask for dated photos and a plain written summary of what they found, including whether the roof has real life left or whether it's time.

This is where honesty matters. If the roof is solid and the photo was wrong, that documentation is your case. If the roof really is worn out, it's better to know now than to find out after a hailstorm when your claim may be paid at a reduced amount.

4. Fix what can be fixed

Some flags are simple. Trimming limbs back from the roof, clearing debris out of valleys and gutters, or replacing a handful of damaged shingles may be all it takes. Ask your agent whether completing a roof repair and sending proof could change the decision before the renewal date.

5. Send your documentation in writing

Send the inspection photos, the written summary, and any receipts for repairs or a past replacement. If your roof was replaced and the insurer's records are out of date, include the invoice or permit showing when the work was done. Keep copies and note who you spoke with and when.

6. Start shopping coverage at the same time

Don't wait on an answer before you look elsewhere. Different insurers use different guidelines, and one company's "too old" may be fine for another. An independent agent can quote several companies at once. If no regular insurer will take the home, ask about the Missouri FAIR Plan mentioned in your notice.

7. Know who to call if something seems wrong

If you think the notice didn't follow the rules or you can't get a straight answer, the Missouri Department of Commerce and Insurance runs an Insurance Consumer Hotline at 800-726-7390 (weekdays, 8 a.m. to 5 p.m.), and you can file a complaint online at insurance.mo.gov. The department suggests contacting your insurer or agent first and keeping notes on every call.

Watch for roof payment schedules too

Even if you keep your policy, read the roof section. Some Missouri policies pay roof claims from wind or hail at actual cash value, or on a schedule that pays a smaller percentage of replacement cost as the roof gets older. The Missouri Department of Insurance's "Raising the Roof" comparison shows some major carriers offer these as optional endorsements in exchange for a lower premium. If your insurer is already worried about your roof's age, it's worth knowing how a future claim would actually be paid. See how hail claim timelines work in Missouri.

If replacement is the answer, can it happen before renewal?

Often, yes. Winter in the Ozarks doesn't stop roof replacement; it just takes some planning around cold snaps and the right installation practices for replacing a roof in cold weather. If you have a renewal date coming up, tell your roofer up front so scheduling can account for it, and check whether Springfield or your town requires a roof permit for the job.

If cost is the worry, look at what's involved in pricing a replacement (what goes into roof replacement cost) and the financing options page before you decide.

Quick answers

Can my insurance company use a drone to look at my roof in Missouri?

Yes. The Missouri Department of Commerce and Insurance has said drone and satellite use isn't prohibited in the state.

How much notice do I get before my policy is not renewed?

At least 30 days under Missouri law (RSMo 375.004), with a specific reason in the notice.

Do I have to replace my roof just because the letter says so?

Not necessarily. Get the photos, get an in-person inspection, and send documentation. Sometimes repairs or proof of a past replacement are enough. Sometimes the roof really is done, and replacing it is the right call.

Will a new roof help me get insured again?

A newer roof usually makes a home easier to insure, but every company has its own guidelines. Ask your agent what they'll need to see.

Get a straight answer on your roof

If your insurance company flagged your roof, get someone on it before you spend a dollar. Titan Roofing will inspect your roof, show you what we find, and tell you honestly whether it needs a repair or a replacement. Schedule your free inspection and estimate or call (417) 815-4833. In the Pleasant Hill area, call (816) 307-0657.

Related: storm and hail damage, residential roofing in Springfield, how to tell if hail damaged your roof.

Sources

Recent Articles

The Titan Journal

See All Articles

Trust In Us Today

Trey, Founder and Owner of Titan Roofing
“We can’t wait to work with you!”
Trey // Founder & Owner
Get A Free Estimate

Get A Free Estimate

What kind of service do you need?